Tired of the same old pumpkin pie every Thanksgiving? Discover exciting alternatives that will elevate your dessert table and impress your guests. We’ve put together a collection of 18+ Thanksgiving pie recipes guaranteed to add variety and deliciousness to your festivities.

Whether you’re a fan of sweet, tangy fruits or rich, creamy fillings, there’s something here for everyone. From classic apple and pecan pies to inventive creations like chocolate bourbon and cranberry almond, the options are endless. These recipes will make you think twice about sticking to the traditional pumpkin pie.

Ready to break free from the pumpkin pie rut? Dive into these delectable Thanksgiving desserts and find your new favorite holiday treat. Each recipe is easy to follow and sure to become a staple at your celebrations. I’ve got you covered with Thanksgiving Pie Recipes that’ll have everyone oohing and aahing.

Thanksgiving Pie Recipes

CLASSIC APPLE PIE

Apple pie is a timeless favorite that brings a comforting sweetness to your Thanksgiving table. The combination of tart apples and a flaky crust creates a perfect balance of flavors. This pie is the epitome of comfort food, making it a must-have for any holiday gathering. Perfect for those who love traditional, crowd-pleasing desserts that never go out of style.

PECAN PIE

Rich, buttery pecan pie offers a sweet, nutty flavor that’s hard to resist. With its gooey filling and crunchy top, this pie is a decadent addition to any Thanksgiving feast. If you’re looking for a dessert that embodies indulgence, pecan pie is the ultimate treat. Perfect for guests who enjoy indulgent, sweet treats with a bit of a crunch.

CHOCOLATE BOURBON PIE

For a dessert with a kick, chocolate bourbon pie combines the richness of chocolate with the warmth of bourbon. This sophisticated treat adds a touch of elegance and indulgence to your dessert table. Perfect for adults who appreciate a refined, flavorful dessert with a hint of indulgence.

CRANBERRY ALMOND PIE

Cranberries and almonds come together in this unique pie to create a tart and nutty flavor profile. It’s a fresh and festive option that stands out from the usual Thanksgiving desserts. Perfect for those looking to add a bright, fruity twist to their holiday dessert spread.

SWEET POTATO PIE

Sweet potato pie is a Southern classic that’s smooth, sweet, and spiced just right. It’s a fantastic alternative to pumpkin pie, offering a similar texture with a richer, deeper flavor. Perfect for fans of creamy, spiced desserts that embody the essence of fall.

MAPLE WALNUT PIE

Maple walnut pie is a delightful combination of earthy nuts and sweet maple syrup. This pie brings the comforting flavors of the season into a deliciously sticky and crunchy dessert. Perfect for nut lovers who want a dessert with depth and a touch of autumn sweetness.

BLUEBERRY PIE

Blueberry pie might be more common in the summer, but its sweet-tart flavor and vibrant color make it a welcome addition to any Thanksgiving table. It’s a lighter, fruitier option that still feels indulgent. Perfect for guests who prefer a lighter, fruitier dessert option.

CHOCOLATE CREAM PIE

For chocolate lovers, chocolate cream pie offers a smooth, velvety filling that’s rich and satisfying. Topped with whipped cream, it’s an irresistible treat that’s perfect for any occasion. Perfect for anyone who can’t get enough of rich, creamy chocolate desserts.

LEMON MERINGUE PIE

Lemon meringue pie adds a zesty, refreshing note to your Thanksgiving dessert lineup. The bright lemon filling contrasts beautifully with the fluffy meringue topping, making it a crowd-pleaser. Perfect for those who love tangy, citrusy flavors that cleanse the palate after a hearty meal.

KEY LIME PIE

Key lime pie offers a tart and sweet flavor with a creamy consistency that’s hard to beat. This pie is a refreshing and light alternative to heavier Thanksgiving desserts. Perfect for guests who enjoy a tropical twist on traditional pies.

CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER PIE

Chocolate and peanut butter are a match made in dessert heaven. This pie combines the best of both worlds with a creamy, rich filling that’s sure to satisfy. Perfect for fans of decadent, over-the-top desserts that blend sweet and salty flavors.

PEAR AND GINGER PIE

Pear and ginger pie offers a sophisticated flavor profile with the sweetness of ripe pears and the warmth of ginger. It’s a unique and elegant dessert option that’s sure to impress. Perfect for those who appreciate nuanced flavors and a touch of spice in their desserts.

BANANA CREAM PIE

Banana cream pie is light, fluffy, and filled with layers of creamy goodness. This pie is a delightful choice for those who want something sweet and creamy without being too heavy. Perfect for guests who enjoy classic, nostalgic desserts with a modern twist.

RASPBERRY RHUBARB PIE

Raspberry rhubarb pie balances the tartness of rhubarb with the sweetness of raspberries, creating a perfectly balanced dessert. It’s a refreshing alternative to more traditional pies. Perfect for those who love a tart and tangy flavor combination with a touch of sweetness.

PUMPKIN CHEESECAKE PIE

For those who still love pumpkin but want something different, pumpkin cheesecake pie offers the best of both worlds. It’s rich, creamy, and full of fall spices, making it a standout dessert. Perfect for fans of pumpkin who want a new twist on the traditional Thanksgiving pie.

BLACKBERRY PIE

Blackberry pie is bursting with juicy berries, creating a sweet and slightly tart dessert that’s perfect for fall. It’s a delicious way to incorporate seasonal fruit into your Thanksgiving spread. Perfect for berry lovers looking for a fresh, fruity dessert option.

CARAMEL APPLE PIE

Caramel apple pie combines the flavors of caramel and apples in a rich, gooey filling that’s both sweet and satisfying. It’s the perfect dessert for those who love the classic taste of apples with an added layer of indulgence. Perfect for guests who love a rich, sweet dessert with a touch of nostalgia.

COCONUT CREAM PIE

Coconut cream pie is a tropical delight with a creamy coconut filling and a light, flaky crust. It’s a refreshing change from the typical fall desserts and brings a taste of the tropics to your table. Perfect for those who want a taste of the tropics at their Thanksgiving table.

HAZELNUT CHOCOLATE PIE

Hazelnut chocolate pie is rich, nutty, and decadent, offering a sophisticated flavor that’s perfect for a holiday treat. It’s an indulgent dessert that feels special and festive. Perfect for chocolate and nut lovers who want a dessert that feels indulgent and special.

As you explore these delicious Thanksgiving pie alternatives, you’re not just trying new recipes—you’re creating unforgettable experiences for your loved ones. Each pie offers a unique twist on traditional flavors, bringing excitement and variety to your holiday table. By choosing one of these recipes, you’re adding a personal touch that will make this Thanksgiving truly special. So go ahead, surprise your guests, and start a new tradition with these mouthwatering desserts. Your Thanksgiving will be the talk of the season, and your pies will be the stars of the show!

Thanksgiving pie recipes are my absolute favorite because they bring so much warmth and joy to the holiday table. There’s something magical about the variety of flavors, from classic apple to rich chocolate bourbon, each pie offering its own unique charm. I love how these pies not only satisfy your sweet tooth but also create a sense of comfort and tradition. Baking them is a labor of love, and sharing them with family and friends makes the holiday feel even more special. Thanksgiving just wouldn’t be the same without these delicious desserts!

This Was All About Thanksgiving Pie Recipes That Are Better Than Pumpkin Pie